Last month I received the Marbella Semi Permanent Eyeliner in one of my monthly subscription boxes, and after playing around with it for a little while I finally am ready to give it my review.
The Marbella Semi Permanent Eyeliner is said to be a smudgeproof and waterproof eye liner that lasts up to 24 hours, but I don't see why you would really need it to last that long. The formula of the Marbella Semi Permanent Eyeliner glides on smoothly and has the color intensity almost of a liquid liner (but not quite as dark and glossy as a liquid liner). I love the preciseness of the felt tip point, allowing to create the thinness of lines.
So what are my thoughts? I can't say I know if the liner lasts up to the 24 hours it claims, because honestly I don't even wear my makeup for more than 10 hours at the most. Although I can say that the Marbella Semi Permanent Eyeliner does last on the lids, the color intensity does seem to fade at around the 6 hour mark (making it not quite as good as some of my favorite liquid liners). I do however love the felt tip point and find the pen packaging very convenient for little touch ups throughout the night.
The Marbella Semi Permanent Eyeliner is probably one of my favorite pen liners at the moment (I have yet to explore the higher end options) for convenience. However, I would not choose to repurchase this for every day use because of the quickly the pen will dry out compared to my other liquid/gel liners.